OptiPeople Resources
Cost of Hire: W2 vs 1099
See what a hire will cost you as an employee and as a contractor, before you make the offer.
Step 1
About the hire
Taxes follow where the employee works, not where your business is based.
Some state programs only apply once you reach a certain size.
Prefilled with the 2026 rate for a new employer. If the state has sent you a rate notice, enter your rate.Some industries start at 3.45%.
A planning estimate. Your carrier sets the real rate by job class.
Benefits and time off
Hiring and setup costs
Contractor
Contractors often charge more per hour than an employee earns, because they cover their own taxes, insurance and time off.
Results
This hire in Illinois
W2 employee
$56,653
per year
- Cost per hour worked
- $29.02
- Employer cost on top of wages
- $4,653 (8.9% of wages)
- First-year total, with hiring costs
- $56,653
1099 contractor
$52,000
per year
- Cost per hour worked
- $25.00
- Employer taxes, workers' comp, benefits
- $0
The contractor costs $4,653 less per year (8.2% less than the employee).
A contractor rate of $29.02 per hour would cost the same as this employee per hour worked.
W2 detail
W2 cost breakdown
| Item | How it's figured | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Wages | $25.00 x 40 hours x 52 weeks | $52,000.00 |
| Social Security (6.2%) | 6.2% of wages up to $184,500 | $3,224.00 |
| Medicare (1.45%) | 1.45% of all wages | $754.00 |
| Federal unemployment (FUTA) | 0.6% of the first $7,000 of wages | $42.00 |
| State unemployment | 3.35% of wages up to $14,250 (Illinois wage base) | $477.38 |
| Workers' comp | 0.3% of wages | $156.00 |
| Health insurance | $0.00 per month x 12 | $0.00 |
| Retirement match | 0% of wages | $0.00 |
| Payroll software | $0.00 per month x 12 | $0.00 |
| Annual employer cost | $56,653.38 | |
| One-time hiring and setup costs | Recruiting, background check, equipment, training | $0.00 |
| First-year total | $56,653.38 |
Paid time off is already inside the wages above. 16 days off means about 128 hours you pay for that are not worked, which is why the cost per hour worked is higher than the hourly rate.
Setup
What you need to set up or file in Illinois
These are steps and filings, not costs. Your payroll provider handles most of them.
- Register for a state unemployment tax account.
- Register for state income tax withholding. You withhold this from the employee's pay and send it in. It is not an added cost to you.
- Withhold federal income tax and the employee's share of Social Security and Medicare. This comes out of the employee's pay.
- Report the new hire to the state within 20 days of the start date.
- Complete Form I-9 and collect a W-4.
- Workers' comp is required from the first employee. With 1 employee, you need it.
- Illinois Secure Choice: if you have 5 or more employees and no retirement plan, you must register and let employees save through payroll. There is no employer contribution.
- Paid Leave for All Workers: employees earn up to 40 hours of paid leave a year. Chicago and Cook County have their own rules.
Beyond cost
Other things to weigh
Cost is one part of the decision. How the work gets done is the other.
W2 employee
- You decide the schedule, the hours and how the work is done.
- They follow your policies, your handbook and your training.
- You can count on their time. They work for you during the hours you set.
- You withhold and pay payroll taxes, carry workers' comp and follow wage and hour rules like overtime.
- They may be eligible for unemployment if the job ends.
- You own the work they produce in the role.
1099 contractor
- You agree on the result and the deadline. They decide how, when and where the work gets done.
- They can work for other companies at the same time, including your competitors unless your agreement says otherwise.
- They set their own schedule and can turn down work. You can't require set hours or attendance.
- Your policies and handbook don't apply to them. The contract does.
- They pay their own taxes, insurance and equipment. You send a 1099-NEC if you pay them $600 or more in a year.
- Either side can end the arrangement under the terms of the contract.
You don't get to pick the label
The law decides whether someone is an employee or a contractor, based on how the work is done. If you set the hours, direct the work and the person works mainly for you, they are likely an employee, whatever the paperwork says. States including Illinois, Massachusetts and New Jersey use strict tests. If a worker is classified wrong, the business can owe back taxes, back wages and penalties. If you're unsure, check before you decide.